You've decided to get help. Now you have three quotes: a general agency in your town, a freelancer recommended by a colleague, an agency specialising in tourism. They all have a nice website and promise "more bookings". How do you choose?
Choosing a marketing agency for your hotel is an important decision: getting it wrong means losing months and budget, sometimes visibility too. Here's how to assess proposals with concrete criteria.
Before you search: know what you need
An agency can't solve a problem you haven't defined. First clarify:
- what's the main problem (visibility, conversion, OTA dependency, pricing, low season)?
- which measurable goals do you want to reach (e.g. +15% direct bookings in 12 months)?
- what's your realistic budget, advertising included?
- what do you want to do in-house and what to delegate?
An initial check-up helps a lot. See hotel marketing check-up: what to review before you invest.
8 questions to ask every agency
- Have you worked with independent hotels? Can I see results and talk to a client?
- How do you measure results? (The right answer talks about bookings and revenue, not just clicks and followers.)
- Who will actually work on my hotel? And how often will we talk?
- What exactly does the service include? What's excluded and what does it cost extra?
- Will the logins to accounts, domain, Analytics and campaigns be in my name?
- How long is the contract? How do I exit?
- What kind of report will I receive, and how often?
- What would you do in the first 90 days for my hotel?
Positive signs
- they ask you lots of questions before proposing anything;
- they talk about direct channel, OTAs, pricing, booking engines: they know the industry;
- they propose priorities, not "everything at once";
- they're transparent about what they can't guarantee (Google rankings, certain results);
- they leave ownership of data and accounts with you.
Warning signs
- guarantees of "first place on Google" or certain results;
- reports full of vanity numbers (impressions, likes) with no bookings. See your agency report shows clicks and impressions: where are the bookings?;
- ad accounts and Analytics registered to the agency;
- long, rigid contracts with no goals;
- standard packages identical for every client;
- no tourism experience.
Generalist or specialist?
An agency specialising in hotels already knows the dynamics of OTAs, seasonality, booking engines and revenue, and speaks your language. A generalist may be very good at a single service (say a website or a campaign) but needs more time to understand the industry. Often the best choice is someone who combines technical skills with first-hand hotel knowledge.
The contract
Make sure it covers:
- included and excluded services, with clear prices;
- goals and indicators;
- ownership of domain, website, content, accounts and data;
- duration, renewal and termination;
- how materials are handed over at the end of the relationship.
Assess after 3–6 months
Compare results with your initial goals: direct bookings, revenue, cost per booking, visibility. If there's no progress and the agency can't explain why, it's time to talk. See how to tell which marketing activities actually bring guests to your hotel.
Frequently asked questions
Freelancer or agency?
A freelancer can be excellent for a specific service and cost less. An agency offers several skills together and continuity. What matters most is hotel experience and transparency.
How much should an agency cost for a small hotel?
It depends on the services. Always compare cost with the goal: for example, how much OTA commission you'd need to save to pay for it. See how much should an independent hotel invest in marketing.
Can I switch agency without losing everything?
Yes, if accounts and data are in your name. That's why it's essential to clarify it from the start. See which logins and data a hotelier needs to control their own marketing.
Want a partner who knows hotels from the inside?
AI Hotel Agency works only with independent, family-run hotels and small groups: it's the industry we know from the inside, because we run hotels in Rimini. Start with our free marketing audit: you get a report with priorities and next steps, no strings attached.



